How the law is perceived in the 20 th century
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14595/PES/03/004Abstract
In this essay the author reflects connection between iusnaturalism and positivism. Dominant discussion is understanding law and morality which represents neverending story. The article analyzes positive law in 20th century represented by H.L. A Hart and natural law development by L.L. Fuller and R. Alexy. Twentieth century can be called a period during which natural law has been shifted towards more positivism within the natural law. Jural positivism can be understood as a doctrine based on the Bentham´s utilitarism which didn´t accept other normative systems to be involved into concept of law. Prominent representatives of this theory have completely excluded moral content of the legal standards and they consider these to be irrelevant for the validity of the law. According to them evaluating standards through moral criteria is not appropriate because this brings chaos into the jural thinking.
Methodology: This essay using from methodology methods of comparation, especially positive law represented by H.L.A. Hart and natural law represented by LL.Fuller, R. Alexy in the20th century and also analyzing connection between law and morality.
References
ALEXY, R.: Theorie der grundrechtes. 2. Frankfurt am Main, 1994
ALEXY, R.: Begriff und Gehtung des Rechts. 2. Freiburg – München, 1994
ARISTOTELES. Rétorika. Praha, 1999
Cicero: O povinnostech. Praha, 1970
DWORKIN, R.: Když se práva berou vážně. Praha, 2001
DWORKIN, R.: Law´s Empire. Cambridge, 1986
FINNIS, J.: Natural Law and Natural Rigts. Oxford, 1980
FULLER, L. L.: Positivism and Fidelity to Law. Harward, Law Review 71, 1958
FULLER, L. L.: Morálka práva. Praha, 1998
HART, H. L. A.: Pojem práva. Praha, 2004
HART, H. L. A.: Recht and Moral. Göttingen, 1978
HART, H. L. A.: Law in the Perspectives of Philosophy. New York University, 1976
HAYEK, F. A. von: The Road to Serfdom. London, 1944
HOBBES, T.: De cive. Výbor z díla. Praha, 1988
HUSTER, S.: Rechte und Ziele. Berlin, 1993
CHOVANCOVÁ, J.: Vízia filozofie v treťom tisícročí a základné zásady právneho myslenia. Bratislava, 2012
CHOVANCOVÁ, J.: Antológia z politickej a právnej filozofie. Bratislava, 2009
KANT, I.: Základy metafyziky mravů. Praha, 1976
KAUFFMAN, H.: Analogia un Natur der Sache. Heidelberg, 1982
KELSEN, H.: Was ist Gerechtigheit. Stuttgard, 2000
KELSEN, H.: Recht und Logik. Wien, 1965
KLOBOUCH, J.: Pluralistické výklady spravedlnosti. Právník, č. 6, Praha, 1995
KNAPP, V.: Teória práva. Praha, 1995
KOTARBINSKI, T.: Kurs logiki dla prawnikow. Warszawa, 1975
LEVIN, J.: How Judges Reason. New York, 1992
RADBRUCH, G.: Zákonné bezprávie a nezákonné právo. Praha, 2011
ŠMID, J.: L. L. Fuller. Distance Revue pro kritické myšlení. Praha, 2007
VALENT, T. – Chovancová, J. a kol.: Texty z dejín právnej filozofie. Bratislava, 2012
WINTR, J.: Charakteristické princípy práva a právních odvetví. Praha, 2002
WINTR, J.: Říše princípů. Praha, 2006
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Articles in Progress in Economic Sciences in printed and online versions are published on the basis of Open Access principles under CC - Creative Commons Attribution. Authors are free to use texts published in the journal.